Who was more fun to seduce Lord Sauron, Ar-Pharazôn or Celebrimbor?

…Fun?

Why, Ar-Pharazôn, of course. 

That is the difference between upholding a facade for many years, sensitive to every detail lest it betray your intentions, and performing a version of yourself that your enemies expect, while letting them do the tedious work of engineering their fate. 

image

More was at stake in Eregion. I had to make myself quite vulnerable to infiltrate the elven kingdoms; my foothold was tenuous, my goals uncertain. Securing power in the west required the cooperation of at least one ruler, and depending on whose ear I gained, the method of influence would change to match. My plans had to remain flexible, my disguise absolute. 

…I was very lucky to have gained the trust of the greatest smith of the Second Age. Of all the rulers of elfindom, wooing the grandson of Fëanor was more than I had dared to hope. If everything had gone as I desired, I could have formed a powerful alliance; our kingdom could have been iron-fast, a seat of industry and ingenuity. I admired Tyelpë very much. It was less a ‘seduction’ than a slow-formed bond. Many times I regretted the deception that lay between us; like a pane of clear glass… easy to forget, until one stretches out a hand. 

“Annatar” was less a lie than an omission; he was comprised of truths, leaving out only what would compromise. What was built on those truths was genuine– but it was not enough. And I learned that too late. 

image

…But the lesson I remembered. I will never again allow myself to become so close to my enemies that I feel sympathy on their behalf– not that this was very difficult. I despised Tar Calion. Only his grandfather was a more despicable despot, and he a less lustful conqueror. 

This may surprise you, but the East is dear to me.
Men, as a race, I do not love, but the people of Umbar, Harad, Khand, and Nurn are different from the Edain; they are less stuffed full of the presumption and arrogance of the Valar. They are rich with gods and heroes unheard of in the West; they have built temples to science and art, they reject no ideas for being too full of what fools call “Melkor’s influence”– as if my Master gave any thought to the taxonomy of nature, or mathematics, or industry. I find this refreshing. The country too is as rich and varied as its people. I have tried to be a good ruler; preserving the existing kingships and systems of governance and religion wherever I could. 

The Sea Kings ran rough-shod over every foreign land they came across. Though the Numenorian influence has long since been integrated into the local milieu, most continue to begrudge the hierarchies brought with it. Their ships and dignitaries are no welcome sight. 

Ar-Pharazôn came with armies and slave galleons. He routed my armies throughout Harad and where he did he left garrisons and exacted tribute, burnt heresies and forbade teachings. …I am no stranger to many of these practices. I have known ages of war, presided over a kingdom’s worth of prisoners. Yet this was a systematic purging of history and culture I have never seen before. I have come to loathe it. 

Calion was an arrogant, brutal little man. It became clear to me that the easiest way to manipulate him was to give him the semblance of victory wherever he sought it. My attacks became feints, my retreats led him farther and farther inland, until he came to my very gates. The sea of tents and banners that stretched into the desert was a glorious, chilling sight indeed… but if it had come to battle, that bloated army would have sunk under its own weight crossing the Mountains of Shadow. 
But I came to him like a tame horse, and stretched out my neck for him, and let him parade me through the streets of Armenelos; a vanquished god, an exotic beast. He would have me perform transformations for his amusements, sing songs for his court like a minstrel or a trained bird. I obliged his every whim, and the more he was reminded of the power he had conquered, the more besotted with he became. I was his private wishing-well, a genie at his command. Calion was a man of many violent passions; he considered himself a great lover of women and, occasionally, young men of certain castes (there was little distinction made in the laws of the land). I do not believe he was ever attracted to me, as I was… but the thought of a powerful warlord on his knees was a potent drug to him; enough to bring him panting and fumbling at his laces– at least, until old age withered such impulses at the root. 

I took a long-steeped and subtle pleasure in the reversal of power; sweet as Umbarim tea. Each submission was a victory, every humiliation I endured became a knot around his soul. He was a clever man, a cautious, paranoid, ambitious man… but precious easy to bind, if one had a little patience. Even while he thought me his toy, I had his ear. How tame he was, how easy to steer once the hooks were in. 

It was his wife that was the true obstacle to my designs. Lucky was I, that time and the chains of propriety had done their work long before I came to power. Her rebellions were toothless, lacking the support or structure necessary to supplant me. Still, she worried me more than Calion and his armies ever did. What an empress she would have been… 

But as I said, no enemy since has come close to my heart. Tormenting her with my victories was part of a daily game that brought me great amusement.

Sending that whole hateful island to hell almost made my loss worthwhile.

image

◕‿◕ ~ S (can’t pass this up >w>)

poppybrownlock-deactivated20171:

Send ◕‿◕ to play with my muse’s hair

@misbehavingmaiar

Poppy
was aware of the fact that she was not alone, and had not been for some
time now, though she had hoped that simply ignoring the shadowy
presence would be enough. The halfling had pretended not to notice the
dark figure that followed her as she went about her day, that she had
not heard the whispering attempts to converse with her, and she was
somewhat heartened that her efforts seemed to be paying off, as the
attempts slowed considerably.

However, she could not ignore
the sooty fingers that combed through her curls as she sat curled up on
her favorite chair. She blinked up at a smiling face, being made much
more receptive and pliable from the simple touch.

“I do not
like it when you ignore me,” a silky voice purred in her ear, bringing a
flush of pink to her cheeks as the fingers continued to tangle through
her hair.

I SOMEHOW MISSED THIS IN MY TAGS AAAAAAAA 8′U 

It’s so impolite to ignore your evil spectral shadow guest! I made tea and everything… 

“They may be dead, but they will forever be a memory, a beacon of hope – and of defiance. Even in death, they defeat you, Shadow.” (didn’t send that ask, but couldn’t keep my muse quiet – LegolasofLasgalen)

And has my legacy been a less enduring beacon of defiance?  

?

What I would use you for, even I am ashamed of. 

I did not expect to feel shame in my current state. There is so little of me left, and yet it proved not immune to kindness. Do not blame yourself for what is to come— If there were any force left in Arda that were capable of staying me from this course, it would have been that kindness; unexpected, simple, and given in innocence, as is your way in life.  

Once this path was aflame with desire; then vengeance, then hatred, and finally, after all feeling had cooled in me, simply habit. Now I think it is the only purpose left to me. I cannot remember now how you became entangled in my schemes to end the story I helped begin… but if there were a way now to complete it without your sacrifice, I would spare you. 
But perhaps you will make the death of the world more poignant than just the extinguishing of ancient, wretched Shadow that no one will mourn. 

At the very least, I will remember you, till I can remember no more. I am sorry. 

Oh the Three, the Three… did I really do all that? It was so very long ago, I can hardly remember! I was not as I am now: In those days I was mad with grief and power, and I wore a body subject to strange whims. But that was ages ago. I can hardly harm a fly, now.

poppybrownlock:

misbehavingmaiar:

poppybrownlock-deactivated20150:

“But if you were given the chance, would you do such things again?” Poppy asked, eyeing him suspiciously.

“Who can be certain of anyone’s character? Certainty is an illusion. Trust is always a matter of faith.”

A whisper of a sigh ruffled the curls on Poppy’s head. “There is only one question that matters to me: do YOU trust me? And if you do not, Poppy, then why is it you continue to return to my side? Why do you ask me to confirm or deny your friends’ doubts?” 

The Shadow peered down into the halfling’s eyes with empty hollows. “Do you, Poppy, believe I am not worthy of trust? Do you too begrudge me a new beginning?”

     “I….” The halfling hesitated, worrying her bottom lip with her teeth. Did she trust him? Could she trust him? Somewhere deep down, Poppy very much wanted to. Despite the repeated, insistent warnings of her friends, he had never done anything to give her cause to doubt him, nor his motives.

     “I very much want to trust you,” She admitted quietly, her gaze lowering to the floor. “You have never given me reason not to, not yet, at least.”

“I wish never to give you reason to doubt.” The Shadow smiled, such as it was able. 

“My dear flower…” Fingers twined in her curling hair. “You cannot know how I treasure your innocence; I who am so acquainted with fear and the harvest of traitors. Your heart is a compass pointing to all things honest and kind–”

The Shadow broke off his words, as if he had over-spoken. The hand paused its stroking, coming forward to raise the halfling’s round little chin. “You and that compass are my best hope in this world. I would never harm you." 

Oh the Three, the Three… did I really do all that? It was so very long ago, I can hardly remember! I was not as I am now: In those days I was mad with grief and power, and I wore a body subject to strange whims. But that was ages ago. I can hardly harm a fly, now.

poppybrownlock:

misbehavingmaiar:

poppybrownlock-deactivated20150:

“But if you were given the chance, would you do such things again?” Poppy asked, eyeing him suspiciously.

“Ah, not everyone is as wise nor as forgiving as you are, sweet flower…”  The Shadow retreated somewhat with a bow. “And many of the elder races have long histories, wherein my name is passed down as a warning. Elves especially are not wont to forgive old crimes… their fear and hatred of me will be long in the forgetting. But you!”  One long finger curled under Poppy’s chin. “You are young, and generous, and understanding. You are not bitter with inherited woes, or timeless sorrow. That is what makes you so precious, little one… You are different. Your heart is bigger than your stature.” 

Poppy was still largely suspicious, but was beginning to soften considerably. “Still though,” she said, fingers fidgeting with her skirts as she took a cautious step back from his reach. “How can I know that I am able to trust you? With so many telling me that you are not worthy of trusting, and not only those of elvenkind, how can I know for certain that your intentions are honest and good?”

"Who can be certain of anyone’s character? Certainty is an illusion. Trust is always a matter of faith.”

A whisper of a sigh ruffled the curls on Poppy’s head. “There is only one question that matters to me: do YOU trust me? And if you do not, Poppy, then why is it you continue to return to my side? Why do you ask me to confirm or deny your friends’ doubts?" 

The Shadow peered down into the halfling’s eyes with empty hollows. "Do you, Poppy, believe I am not worthy of trust? Do you too begrudge me a new beginning?" 

Poppy & The Shadow (and other varied forms)

poppybrownlock:

Because I just can’t get enough of the height thing….

Here is Poppy and Sauron’s ‘most human-ish’ form (according to misbehavingmaiar). [7 ft]

image

Poppy and the Shadow [9.5 ft]

image

And then finally, Poppy and the super massive holy moly don’t sit on my Hobbit please Sauron. [12 ft]

image

Aaaaw, kitten-sized! *picks up and pets*

Oh the Three, the Three… did I really do all that? It was so very long ago, I can hardly remember! I was not as I am now: In those days I was mad with grief and power, and I wore a body subject to strange whims. But that was ages ago. I can hardly harm a fly, now.

poppybrownlock:

misbehavingmaiar:

poppybrownlock-deactivated20150:

“But if you were given the chance, would you do such things again?” Poppy asked, eyeing him suspiciously.

The Shadow exhaled a breathy laugh and set large ethereal hands on the halfling’s shoulders.

“It’s hardly a question of would. I cannot! And why would I choose to, even I could? There are no great powers left in the Middle Realm that might tempt me, and I have no kingdom of my own left to defend. Such bloody deeds are the product of grand ambitions, vengeance, and survival… Wouldn’t you say I am beyond such things now? What should an old, toppled shade like myself do, except eke out his days until the End in peace?” 

"If all that you say is true,” Poppy began, biting at her bottom lip. “And you only wish to exist in peace now until your days end…then why is it that everyone warns me against you, and says you intend to use me for some nefarious purpose? If you were truly harmless, would they not realize such and leave me be?”

“Ah, not everyone is as wise nor as forgiving as you are, sweet flower…”  The Shadow retreated somewhat with a bow. “And many of the elder races have long histories, wherein my name is passed down as a warning. Elves especially are not wont to forgive old crimes… their fear and hatred of me will be long in the forgetting. But you!”  One long finger curled under Poppy’s chin. “You are young, and generous, and understanding. You are not bitter with inherited woes, or timeless sorrow. That is what makes you so precious, little one… You are different. Your heart is bigger than your stature.” 

Oh the Three, the Three… did I really do all that? It was so very long ago, I can hardly remember! I was not as I am now: In those days I was mad with grief and power, and I wore a body subject to strange whims. But that was ages ago. I can hardly harm a fly, now.

poppybrownlock-deactivated20150:

“But if you were given the chance, would you do such things again?” Poppy asked, eyeing him suspiciously.

The Shadow exhaled a breathy laugh and set large ethereal hands on the halfling’s shoulders.

“It’s hardly a question of would. I cannot! And why would I choose to, even I could? There are no great powers left in the Middle Realm that might tempt me, and I have no kingdom of my own left to defend. Such bloody deeds are the product of grand ambitions, vengeance, and survival… Wouldn’t you say I am beyond such things now? What should an old, toppled shade like myself do, except eke out his days until the End in peace?" 

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started